|
Allard, 200922) |
Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
Randomized controlled Trial |
72 |
To investigate the association between coagulopathy and PIH |
Post hoc analysis; GSC <8 (severe TBI) |
Coagulopathy, PIH, mortality |
Mean DD levels(n=42): Survivors- 4434(2408,9824); non survivors- (18000 (10000,20000) (p=0.002); Coagulopathy associated with progression of PIH. |
High DD a significant independent predictor of mortality in severe TBI |
|
Asami, 20229) |
Japan |
Prospective study |
335 |
DD at hospital arrival as predictor of neurological prognosis in head injury by RTA |
GCS <8, only RTA cases |
GOS at discharge |
Univariate analysis- DD >17.4 µg/ml-poor prognosis; multivariate - DD>89.3 µg/ml -independent predictor of poor outcome. |
D dimers at arrival can be independent predictor of poor outcome in severe head injuries due to RTA |
|
Bayir, 200610) |
Turkey |
Prospective study |
62 |
To determine the use of fibrinolytic markers as prognostic indicator in isolated head injury |
Isolated head injury presented within 3hrs of trauma |
GCS and Mortality with D dimers and others like PT PTT FDP platelets |
DD µg/ml (mean +SD) - survivors=0.7+/-0.3; Non survivors= 1.0+/-0.0 with p <0.001 |
GCS and fibrinolytic markers in first 3hr in isolated head injury cases can be useful for prognostication |
|
Berger, 201530) |
Pittsburgh |
Retrospective and prospective cohorts |
195 |
To determine DD would increase in children with TBI especially mild abusive head trauma |
Prospective- cases- <4yr at risk of abusive head trauma with abnormal CT; retrospective- cases- <4yr abnormal CT due to trauma, |
Correlation of DD with cases (CT positive findings) and controls, age, GCS and mechanism of injury |
Median (IQR) DD higher in cases vs. controls (1.25 [0.70/4.25] vs. 0.44 [0.29/0.60] μg/L) FEU. The corresponding Mann-Whitney was significant at p < 0.000. |
DD can be used in young children at risk of mild abusive head trauma who might benefit from head CT and other evaluation |
|
Bredbacka, 19942) |
Sweden |
Prospective study |
20 |
To test whether SF, Antithrombin and D dimer in patients with isolated head trauma associated with worse outcome |
RTA, gunshot, assault patients with head injury <24hr |
DD at admission with admission GCS and discharge GOS |
DD significantly elevated and correlated with worse GCS and not with GOS scores |
SF seems to be a better predictor of outcome. DD not correlated with GOS |
|
Chen, 20136) |
China |
Retrospective |
265 |
To assess post-traumatic coagulation disorders association with early post-traumatic cerebral infarction and influence on clinical outcome. |
Isolated TBI admitted <4hr with GCS <12 and AIS <3 |
GOS 3 months after trauma. D dimer at 12hr of admission |
DD is associated with poor outcome in these patients with OR 2.472, 95%CI (1.263-4.845) P =0.012 |
Elevated DD might serve as a marker of PTCI and increased morbidity and mortality |
|
Chen, 202245) |
China |
Retrospective |
479 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Chhabra, 201335) |
India |
Prospective study |
208 |
To assess the incidence of coagulopathy and correlation with prognosis in patients with isolated TBI |
Isolated TBI with GCS <12 (mod to severe TBI) |
DD measured on day of admission and at 3days. Coagulopathy ....... |
DD associated coagulopathy, which has an effect on prognosis, but DD was not directly correlated with prognosis |
coagulopathy and severity of TBI are strong predictors of outcome |
|
DeFazio, 20141) |
Virginia |
Retrospective study |
44 |
To evaluate the biomarker profiles of post-traumatic indicators for early clinical trends after severe TBI. |
Severe TBI (GCS 8) admitted <3hr after injury and no corticosteroids used |
DD measured at 24hr, 48hr and 72hr time point. Poor clinical status - death or GCS <8) and improved clinical status (GCS >8) |
DD ng/ml at 24hr- 3769.55 (ROC) 0.86 (AUC) 0.73-0.99 (CI) 0.821 p=0.00 |
DD values at admission are not significantly different, but DD at 24hr associated with poor clinical status (p=0.00) |
|
Dekker, 201636) |
The Netherlands |
Prospective |
92 |
To examine the role of coagulopathy with cerebral oxygenation in patients with TBI |
Moderate to severe TBI, all measurements done at admission, AIS >3 |
Hematological parameters like- PT, APTT, DD, Fibrogen; cerebral and systemic tissue oxygenation by ABG analysis, NIRS |
Lactate levels and base excess showed correlation with DD levels (r=0.40, p=0.029); (r=-0.39; p=0.027) |
TBI coagulopathy is more profound in patients with systemic hypoperfusion; coagulopathy is more severe in patients with higher grades of injury |
|
Fair, 202116) |
Portland, Oregon, USA |
Prospective, observational study |
141 |
Coagulation profile in patients with intra-cranial hemorrhage and to know the relationship in patients of PIH |
Isolated TBI with AIS >3 |
DD measured at admission, 6,12,24,48hrs, AIS and ISS scores measured |
DD was higher in patients with PICH at admission (p=0.04) peaked at 6hr, and decreased trend over 48hr |
DD may be useful as a predictor of PIH |
|
Fouad, 201427) |
Egypt |
Case control study |
66 |
DD as prognositic marker in TBI in children |
Isolated TBI |
GCS, CT at admission, 3rd day, 14th day |
The best cut-off point at 1st day was 10.5 with sensitivity 89.5 %, specificity 100.0 %, PPV 100.0% and NPV 93.1 % |
In children who meet clinical criteria for a head CT scan after trauma, low plasma D-dimer strongly suggests the absence of significant brain injury |
|
Fujiwara, 202246) |
Japan |
Retrospective analysis |
458 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Genet, 201337) |
Houston, Texas. |
Prospective observational cohort study |
23 |
To investigate the hemostatic response to Isolate TBI; severe TBI + other injuries, non TBI |
Patients meeting the criteria of full trauma team activation and had an arterial cannula |
DD measured at time of admission; 30day mortality |
DD in isolated TBI (n=23), 170ng/ml (133-174); sTBI+other (n=15)- 173(171-176); non TBI (n=42) 145 (61-171) with p=0.003 |
The hemostatic, vascular, and endothelial responses may be the same in isoTBI and non-TBI patients |
|
Grenander, 200138) |
Sweden |
A prospective, controlled, randomized, open pilot study |
28 |
To assess if antithrombin treatment reduced progress of brain contusion, decrease ICU stay and improved outcome (GOS) |
Isolated TBI, GCS 4 -12, within 12 hr of injury |
blood samples are drawn at admission, 8,16,24,36 and 48hr followed by daily till 5days. |
DD at admission- AT group (5626+/-3555); control group (5623+/-3802). |
AT used to treat patient with severe TBI resulted in marginal reduction of hypercoagulation |
|
Gupta, 201621) |
Punjab, India. |
Prospective study |
50 |
To know the impact of coagulation profile derangements and their effect on outcome |
Isolated TBI, two groups with GCS 9-13 (moderate injury), GCS <9 (severe) |
GOS score and comparison with presenting GCS and DIC score |
DD 2812+/- 1351 in expired (n=20), 2616+/-1703.86 in discharged (n=4); p=>0.05 |
Patients with isolated head injury are at a risk of development of coagulation abnormalities, which is associated with poor outcome |
|
Hoffmann, 200132) |
Kansas City, MO |
Prospective study |
319 |
To assess DD as screening tool for traumatic or spontaneous intracranial hemorrhage |
<24hr, GCS <13, age >60; both traumatic and non-traumatic |
DD correlated with CT findings of intracranial hemorrhage |
Sensitivity: 84.0% (95% CI = 63.7% to 95.5%); specificity: 55.8% (95% CI = 50.1% to 61.5%); positive predictive value: 13.9% (95% CI = 8.8% to 19.7%); negative predictive value: 97.6% (95% CI = 94.1% to 99.3%). |
The D-dimer assay cannot be relied upon as a substitute for an emergent CT scan of the head when intracranial hemorrhage is clinically suspected |
|
Hosseininejad, 202331) |
Iran |
Cross-sectional study |
74 |
To investigate whether DD and CRP can be used as a prognostic marker for clinical outcomes in patients with mild TBI |
Mild TBI with GCS of 14,15 |
DD levels correlated with CT findings |
The sensitivity and specificity for positive CT findings were 100 and 98.50% p<0.001 at cut off point of 0.90 for DD |
CRP and DD levels of mild TBI patients can be used to protect against CT induced radiation exposure and subsequent disorders. |
|
Kuo, 200429) |
Taiwan |
Prospective |
61 |
To find a better predictor for outcome in patients with head injury |
All head injury patients |
DD measured at admission |
DD correlated with CT midline shift, coagulopathy score with GOS |
Coagulopathy score >4 is a significant predictor of outcome in severe head injury patients |
|
Langness, 201833) |
United States |
Retrospective |
663 |
To validate the association of DD in TBI, to determine whether DD may aid in limiting unnecessary CT head if used as a screeing tool |
<18yr with suspected TBI and had both CT and DD |
DD measured at 6hr, 12 and 48hrs; presence of TBI, clinically significant TBI or no TBI; correlation of DD with CT findings |
100% NPV for the presence of TBI when the DD threshold was set to <100pg/µl and this would have avoided 97 head CT in their series |
low DD values accurately predict absence of Clinically important TBI for pediatric patients with head injury |
|
Murshid, 200220) |
Saudi Arabia |
Prospective |
70 |
To characterize the coagulopathy complicating head injury by monitoring hemostatic markers at different timings of measurement |
GCS <12 with head injury resulting from RTA |
DD measured from peripheral venous, arterial and jugular venous samples and at different timings daily over 4days |
DD at admission - peripheral venous-1115ug/ml, arterial -1288ug/ml and jugular 888ug/ml; DD concentrations dropped at all sites over days. GOS measured at 6months did not show any correlation with hemostastic measurements |
Hemostatic activation is a common phenomenon after head injury and is more prominent in cerebrovascular than in peripheral blood. |
|
Nakae, 201940) |
Japan |
Retrospective |
380 |
To examine the relationship between age and coagulation and fibrinolytic parameters occurring within first 12hr after injury |
TBI with AIS >3 and blood samples taken <1hr post injury |
Age/sex/GCS/AIS and Coagulation parameters at 1hr, 3, 6 and 12hrs post injury |
DD was significantly elevated in both adult and pediatric groups, with no significant differences between groups. The independent risk factor for poor prognosis was DD level at admission OR 6.70 95% CI (1.67-142.59) (p<0.001) |
In acute phase of TBI, pediatric patients have prolonged PT-INR and APTT and lower fibrinogen levels than adults but are not significant; DD was an independent prognostic factor in pediatric patients. |
|
Nakae, 202139) |
Japan |
Retrospective |
468 |
To investigate the relationship between patient outcomes after FFP transfusion and to evaluate the correlation with DD levels at admission |
severe isolated TBI- intracranial AIS >3; extracranial AIS <3. |
GOS at discharge and at 3months; DD at admission |
DD at admission was significantly associated with a decrease in fibrinogen following injury in FFP non transfusion group (R2 =0.29, P<0.0001) |
Outcomes of isolated TBI were significantly correlated with maintaining fibrinogen levels >150mg/dl which can be predicted with admission DD levels |
|
Nozawa, 202044) |
USA |
Cross-sectional study |
364 |
To demostrate how well low DD helps in ruling out significant intracranial injury |
Ped patients with suspected head trauma and had CT and DD values measured less than 24hr post injury |
DD measured <24hr, correlated with CT findings |
DD mean - abnormal CT 32.5(98.8) n=123; 5.9 (12.2) n=241 with P<0.01; cut off set of DD at 0.5µg/mL sensitivity 100% (95%CI: 95.6-100.0%); high NPV 100% (95% CI: 93.5-100.0%) ; low specificity: 34.0% (95%CI: 28.1–40.4%); and low PPV 43.6% (95%CI: 37.7–49.6%) |
Low plasma D-dimer (≤0.5 lg/mL) is useful to limit the use of CT in children by excluding traumatic ICI or SF. |
|
Pahatouridis, 201041) |
Greece |
Prospective |
61 |
To investigate the incidence of DIC in moderate head injury patients and the safety of early use of LMW heparin |
Moderate head injury- GCS 9-12 and without need for surgical intervention |
Blood samples are drawn at 3-6hr, 24, 48, 72hr post admission; correlated with GCS |
DD strongly elevated >2000ng/ml in 83% patients at first day, by 3rd day 55% normalised but 45% remained with DD above 2000ng/ml. lower GSC scores correlated with increased DD levels. |
Patients with moderate TBI are at a serious risk of developing brain intravascular microthrombosis. This study supports the early use of LMW Heparin. |
|
Peng, 201918) |
China |
Prospective |
42 |
To investigate the expression of plasma cys-c, DD, CRP in patients with PIH and their significance for severity and outcome. |
Confirmed craniocerebral injury by CT, no other tissue injury, no hematological abnormalities, no infectious diseases |
GCS and GOS; fasting peripheral venous blood on the morning of day of diagnosis and healthy participants as controls |
DD 5.34+/-1.35mg/L significantly higher than controls 1.37+/-0.33mg/L P<0.01; DD levels in severe coma group were higher than mild coma group (p<0.05); DD levels were significantly higher in poor outcome groups P<0.05 |
Increased plasma cys-c, DD and CRP levels may be involved in occurrence and development of IPHI after craniocerebral injury. The measurement of these markers helps in diagnosis and prognosis. |
|
Saggar, 200923) |
Jaipur, India. |
Prospective |
80 |
To examine various hemostatic abnormalities in patients with head injury and their role in predicting early mortality. |
Mod (GCS 9-13) to severe (GCS <8) closed head injury with no history of hematological abnormalities |
DIC scores compared with outcomes using GOS |
DD levels in expired GOS 1 (n=34) 2.47+/-0.50; levels in discharged GOS 3-5 (n=32) 0.50+/-0.50 p<0.01 |
Hemostatic evaluation can predict mortality irrespective of GCS score in patients with head injury |
|
Scherer, 199842) |
Germany |
Prospective study. |
24 |
To determine the degree of regional and systemic coagulation activation after isolated severe head injury. |
Isolated head injury GCS <8, admitted <6hr of injury; control group with isolated bone fractures |
Coagulation variables measured every 2-3days till discharge from central venous cath/ jugular bulb cath/ radial artery; GOS measured at discharge |
DD at admission was significantly elevated in head trauma patients (p<0.005), with no difference in concentration in cerebrocentral blood than in central venous blood. No correlation was found with clinical outcomes. |
Head trauma often activates the coagulation system, potentially causing fibrin deposition. The shift from initial hypercoagulability to disseminated intravascular coagulation in some cases raises concerns about the coagulation system's ability to adequately control traumatic events. |
|
Shibahashi, 201743) |
Japan |
Retrospective study, |
240 |
To analyse the risk factors and outcomes of SDH development following surgical evacuation for unilateral acute SDH |
Patients who underwent surgical evacuation for unilateral SDH and had post op CT scan |
GCS on admission, time of injury and blood tests |
DD in SDH group - 73.1 (38.9, 134.4); controls -33.5 [16.9, 73.8] (p=0.13) |
Low fibrinogen is a significant risk factor for SDH development in cases mentioned in objective. DD values are not significant. |
|
Sun, 201124) |
China |
Prospective observational study. |
785 |
Estimate the incidence of coagulopathy and DIC in patients with TBI and to correlate with outcome |
Adult isolated head injury (AIS >2) patients with |
DIC score, GCS and GOS |
DD in non-survivals (GOS 1, n=44) 4.69+/-3.82; GOS 2-3, n=36 3.62+/-3.46; GOS 4-5, n=162 1.96+/-1.86 p<0.05 |
Higher DIC score are prognostic for PHI incidence |
|
Swanson, 201034) |
California |
Prospective cohort observational study |
57 |
Investigate biomarkers to predict the absence of TBI in children |
Suspected head injury patients underwent CT according to children's head injury algorithm, admission time DD levels |
Hematological parameters correlated with CT findings |
DD levels in CT positive cases (n=38), 5000 (154–5000) ; in CT negative cases (n=19) 688 (150–5000) p<0.001 |
In children with clinical criteria for head CT after trauma, low DD suggest no significant brain injury |
|
Takahashi, 199726) |
Japan |
Prospective |
43 |
To investigate fibrinolytic parameters like DD as a reliable indicator of extent of brain damage in severe head injury patients and predicting outcomes. |
Isolated TBI with GCS 3-14 |
DD at admission with admission GCS and discharge GOS |
Group 3 (Dead) had significantly higher D-dimer levels than Group 2 (severe disability) (p < 0.05) and Group 1 (good recovery) (p < 0.0001). DD > 5 µg/ml, 92% of patients died, DD < 1 µg/ml, all patients had good recovery or moderate disability. |
DD correlated well with the extent of brain damage in patients with head injuries, and these values may predict the outcomes. |
|
Tong, 201217) |
China |
Retrospective study, |
530 |
To investigate the risk factors related to PIH in TBI |
Isolated TBI with no history of haematological abnormalities |
Coagulation variables and GOS at 6months |
DD in PIH group (n=139) 80.20+/-76.75; non PIH group (n=359) 11.41+/-14.05; p<0.0001; OR 1.085 (95%CI 1.066–1.104) |
Primary haematoma with abnormal DD levels should have an earlier and dynamic CT scan for the detection of PIH as early as possible. |
|
Tu, 202125) |
China |
Prospective |
92 |
Coagulation-related indicators combined with GCS in evaluating the prognosis of craniocerebral injury. |
History of craniocerebral injury with admission <5hr from injury |
Fasting coagulation parameters and GCS |
DD in Survived group(n=58) 1.86±0.52 g/L; deceased (n=34) 4.54±0.86 P<0.001 |
Coagulation-related indicators combined with GCS can effectively evaluate the prognosis of patients with craniocerebral injury. |
|
Wada, 201728) |
Japan |
Retrospective study |
92 |
To test the hypothesis of DIC affects the outcome of patients with TBI |
Severe isolated TBI with AIS >3 |
Coagulation parameters measured at 4hr, 8, 16, 24hr |
DD values are significantly high in patients with hyperfibrinolysis p=0.000; DIC score as predictor of mortality has OR 1.717 (95%CI: 1.059-2.784) p=0.028 |
DIC with hyperfibrinolysis, affects the outcome of patients with isolated TBI |
|
Xu, 202019) |
China |
Retrospective study |
192 |
To describe the relationship between DD and Fibrinogen ratio and PIH after TBI |
Patients admitted <6hr after trauma, AIS <3, two CT scans done within 24hr of admission |
DD: Fibrinogen ratio correlated with the incidence of progressive hemorrhagic injury |
DD in PHI patients (n=43) 4.89 (4.31–6.87) mg/l; in non-PHI patients (n=149) 4.02 (3.28–5.12) P<0.001 |
DD:Fibrinogen ratio was a strong predictor of Progressive hemorrhagic injury |
|
Yabuno, 202215) |
Japan |
Retrospective cohort study |
826 |
To investigate outcome for ICU survivors after moderate to severe TBI and to assess predictive factors |
Moderate to severe TBI, AIS >3 follow up 2yr |
DD levels correlated with return to home and return to work |
DD ug/ml in non-RH (n=24) 58.62+/-51.34; RH (n=83) 36.44+/-39.99 p=0.028; DD for return-to-work p=0.082 |
Age and GCS on admission are predictive of Return to home and work for ICU survivors |
|
Youssef, 201511) |
Egypt |
Prospective study |
67 |
To evaluate clinical and lab markers for predicting outcome of TBI in pediatric patients |
Isolated TBI with positive CT findings |
GCS, routine lab investigations and coagulation parameters at D1 and D7 and compared in non survivors and survivors |
DD at D1 in non survivors (n=28), 32.5(18.9-40.6) and survivors (n=39), 4.2 (2.1-6.8) p<0.001. DD at D7 compared in non survivors and survivors has p<0.001 |
SGPT, GCS, DD were the important clinical and lab markers for predicting mortality in TBI |